Elroy Accent Chair with Wooden Legs

Room×Lab Review · Review updated September 1, 2026

The Elroy wins on compact comfort, with real fit and durability caveats

All 370 distinct available comment-bearing Target guest reviews tied to the shared Elroy Accent Chair family were studied, including current Cream Faux Shearling, Brown Velvet and Olive Green Velvet versions and historical Natural Linen and tan offerings. Ratings-only submissions were not treated as comments. Findings apply to this shared Elroy chair family; upholstery-specific color, texture, care and dimensions may differ.

Room×Lab rating: 7.4 out of 10 (medium confidence). Strong owner satisfaction and an attractive small-room footprint lift the Elroy, while polarized body fit, limited upper-back support and isolated leg or upholstery failures keep it from scoring higher. Evidence is broad at Target but thin for long-term independent use.

• Comfort depends on how you sit: 167 favorable mentions; 12 lower-rating concerns — Owners often describe comfortable compact accent seating, while concerns focus on firmness, a low back, limited upper-back support and a pillow that pushes the sitter forward.
• Compact dimensions suit smaller rooms: 126 favorable mentions; 9 lower-rating concerns — The smaller footprint is a recurring advantage, but some taller or broader adults describe the seat and back as undersized.
• Durability is generally favorable, with isolated failures: 43 favorable mentions; 9 lower-rating concerns — Positive durability experiences outnumber concerns in the inspected comments, but cracked or split legs, chipped finishes and pet-damaged upholstery are credible household-specific anecdotes.

Before buying

Measure your seat-depth and back-support needs, then confirm the exact upholstery variant’s assembly, care and warranty terms before ordering.

More accent chairs reviews

• Mod 35" Lounge Chair - Blue BerryArticle · 1,902 owner comments checked
• POÄNG ArmchairIKEA · 1,697 owner comments checked
• Nomad Leather Club ChairBurrow · 1,389 owner comments checked
• Nomad ArmchairBurrow · 1,373 owner comments checked
• Gabriola 34" Lounge Chair - Ivory BoucléArticle · 604 owner comments checked
• Vernon Upholstered Barrel Accent ChairThreshold x Studio McGee · 443 owner comments checked

Browse every accent chairs review

More accent chairs

Browse every accent chairs in the catalog

• Furniture
• Lighting
• Rugs
• Décor
• Bedding & Textiles
• Kitchen & Table